Friday, November 04, 2005

Aren't we colored, after all.

Race. Ethnicity. Jokes. Slurs. Affirmative action. Interracial relationships. You can’t avoid it. Sooner or later, you’ll step on someone’s toes and someone will step on yours. Do you become profusely apologetic for the rest of your life? Plead the 5th and live your life in ignorance? Where is the line? Is there a line at all?

I walked in on an interesting lunch conversation today. Ruchi, who is Indian, was questioning the political correctness of a current campaign we are designing for a restaurant chain called Oriental Wok. (One could argue that the name itself stirs dissent.) Andrea, who is white, was hyperventilating at the mere thought that their smart campaign might step on racial toes and frantically paced the floor defending her work and the campaign. The campaign sought to poke fun specifically at Caucasians who tattooed themselves with Chinese symbols without knowing the real meaning and also sought to meld Eastern stereotypes into the mix. One of the headlines read something like, “You are as ugly as arranged marriage.”

Frankly, I didn’t think the lines made much sense and took too much thought, but surely the issue of race and racial lines hit the heart of many. As a first generation Chinese American woman, I have a lot to say about this.

A temporary salve, childhood kept me innocent and unaware of racial lines. I was born in Georgia with parents who grew up in Taiwan – another world, another generation apart. Mandarin was my first language, but I had to learn English to go to school. I grew up here in Cincinnati. Despite going to a Chinese church, I grew accustomed to being around Caucasians all the time. To this day, I am more attracted to Caucasian males than any other ethnicity. (I am also uncomfortable around large groups of Asians. Weird, huh?)

Then puberty hit. And oh no – suddenly I was sucked into a whirlwind of an identity crisis. I wanted to be pretty, popular, and accepted. The first time I put on a sleeveless shirt, my mother gasped in horror because she could see the outline of my bra. I was marched upstairs to undress. I was smart, clumsy, and laughed at by the boys. Oh how I envied the popular girls…too dumb to spell their own name, but they had the guys tripping over themselves. I attributed their popularity to the fact that they were white, and it would be years before I stopped wishing for big blue eyes.

In high school, some boys at the Chinese church wore bracelets engraved with the word “Chigger”, a combination of the words “chink” and “nigger”. They defended themselves, saying that it’s okay to make fun of your own race, you just can’t make fun of another race. Was that true? I didn’t know, but I was horrified.

Over the years, girls would tell me to be happy that I’m Chinese. “The boys want you more,” they’d say. “You’re different. You’re exotic.” Was that a good thing? Should I be happy that a lot of men have Asian fetishes or should I be angry because I’m treated differently? In the same way, should I be happy that affirmative action helped me get into college or should I be angry that I’ll never know if my academics could have pulled that weight?

One of my greatest pet peeves is people who think that, just because I’m Chinese, I can’t be American. They don’t recognize the difference between nationality and ethnicity.

I’ll never forget the day Jason and I sat down to have dinner with his best friend Joe and Joe’s parents. A lover of sauce, I was drowning my steak in BBQ sauce and praising it. Rose, Joe’s mother, remarked, “Oh honey, you’ve never heard of this sauce before? Don’t worry, I think it’s an American thing.”

You could have cut the silence with a knife. “Moooom!” Joe whispered. “She IS American.”

It wasn’t the first time something like that’s happened, and it certainly won’t be the last. Take your pick – kids pulling at the corners of their eyes, playing “Chinese fire drill” on the roads (we never invented that, btw), guys hitting on me because they have an “Asian thing”, butchering my last name, asking me “Where are you from? No, where are you REALLY from?”, friends trying to “kung fu” me, the people who see Jason and I as an interracial couple before they see anything else.

Years back there was a national outcry and debate about who, if anyone, could say the word “nigger”. The topic resurfaced when Eminem became popular. And then there was that one politician who mistakenly said the word…what was it…”niggardly”?…in a speech.

I will end this post by saying that Jason, bless his heart, surprised me when he told me that my ethnicity played no part in his attraction to me. Between the two of us, I am probably the more discriminatory, since I have an affinity towards white men.

A few months ago, we were serving in the children’s ministry and sat down with our kids to listen to the children’s leader give a lesson on acceptance. “You should love everyone, even those different from you. Like, take the Orientals for example. They may be different from me, but I still accept and love them,” he preached.

My mouth hung open in a soundless surprise. Jason, equally stunned, fought the urge to laugh. Here was a white man teaching a room full of white children a lesson on acceptance by using an example about Orientals. And I was the only Asian (and minority, for that matter) in the room. To this day, Jason calls me an “Oriental” in a redneck drawl as an inside joke.

So what do you think? What is your racial story? Are there lines to be drawn? If so, where?

19 Comments:

Blogger Concert Josh said...

I like to say that I am a pretty politically incorrect person. I HATE the phrase “ _______ - American” except when someone has just immigrated to the States. I say things like “that’s gay” all the time. I call my Mexican co-worker ‘lazy’. None of this is said to offend anyone. It is who I am. I understand if someone is offended, but that just means that they don’t know me well.

At the same time, my roommate and I are the only two ‘white’ people on our block. The other day as I was walking from my car to my front door, I heard the punk teenage gang-banger-wanna-be and his friend yelling “Honk, Honk” at me as I walked by. I didn’t realize until talking to my downstairs Puerto Rican neighbor that they ‘slurring’ me. I felt an instant, but short-lived rage. I understood at that instant how words can and do offend, especially when they are said to do just that.

In my opinion, it is hard not to generalize, or group people into a stereotype as a whole. I try to take individuals as just that, individuals. I still hold certain stereotypes, like I am sure everyone else does. I just don’t throw anyone into that generalization without giving them a chance as an individual first. I don’t see color, but I sure do smell assholes.

5:28 PM  
Blogger Beckalicious said...

I like to think I'm pretty open-minded, too. A great amount of it is in how you are raised, what you are exposed to, and the reactions of those around you.

I'm whiter than white. I don't even like saying that I'm Italian-German, because I'm not... that's not how I "identify" myself. It's my heritage but not ME, if that makes any sense.

We live in a very mixed-race neighborhood (Hispanic, African-American, Indian - from India, not Native American, the largest Sudanese population in the city). My kids go to school with kids of every race, and they are friends with and kind to everyone. If there is ONE thing they take away from my parenting them (aside from all the negative traits that they've picked up from me so far), it's that they need to accept everyone and be kind to everyone, regardless of color, sexual orientation, language, etc.

I can't pretend to understand what anyone of another race/ethnicity goes through on a daily basis. I've never been the object of ridicule or slurs, although I'm sure that will happen someday.

7:46 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

darn o-re-rentals, always ruinin' the math curve!
(love you baby)

1:45 AM  
Blogger kimananda said...

Well, categorizing things (and, by extension, people) is a natural part of human cognition. The negative side of that is of course when we're put into categories that aren't helpful to us.

For me, I don't have a racial story, but I feel my Americanism very clearly, not just since I've lived in Europe, but especially since then. Americans, more than most other nationalities, are put into a predetermined box, which subtly (or not so subtly) affects the way in which we are seen in the rest of the world (usually negatively).

The immigration debate in many parts of Europe also hinges largely upon how people categorize other people, in this case based not just upon nationality or ethnicity but upon religion. I know that any negativity I get is nothing compared to what my fellow immigrants who are Muslim get.

As for where to draw the line, the problem is that everyone will want the line drawn differently. Some will want to draw the line in a tight circle around themselves. Some will want the line to encircle all of humanity. And of course, most will be somewhere in between those two extremes. And who is ultimately to decide, given that there will most likely never be consensus?

8:15 AM  
Blogger Trish said...

Leslie, have you ever been published? I always enjoy reading your blog, but this entry in particular is very well written and if you haven't tried to get published before, you should start now.

That said, my father's family is very New Jersey Italian, and my sister and I are the only cousins who grew up in Connecticut, outside of that culture. I feel uncomfortable in large groups of Italians - like I'm an extra on an episode of the Sopranos.

12:38 PM  
Blogger The mini ninja said...

Josh - why do you hate the phrase "_______-American"? I don't refer to myself very often, but I suppose if I did, I would call myself Chinese-American. However, Jason says that I am American with a Chinese ethnicity. Is there a difference?

Actually, you remind me a lot of Jason...or most American men, for that matter. He says "that's gay" sometimes (especially when I try to get him to try on a pink shirt), and I always correct him. He also calls himself "whitey", makes women jokes (well, just ONE, we're trying to get him a new joke), and calls me "Oriental". It's all in jest, as I'm sure yours is too.

What interests me is that you didn't realize that you were being racially slammed, and then when you did, you were angry. Were you angry because they called you honky, or because they weren't joking?

You're a wise man to take people as individuals and not the labels that come before them. "I don’t see color, but I sure do smell assholes." What a good line. You may not see color, but it seems like the kids on your block do. And when does a person who's "just joking" become an asshole? Where's the line?

2:38 PM  
Blogger The mini ninja said...

Becky - Ah yes, the classic Nature v. Nurture argument. I also tend to side more with the Nurture side, especially in this case. I also think that how you treat people has a lot to do with choice. My parents continue to experience prejudice, yet they also exercise prejudice...particular against black and fat people.

You have also made the good point that who you are has a lot to do with how you see yourself. I happen to identify with being Chinese...not as much as a native, but enough to embrace the language, the art, the beauty, and the FOOD. :) It's great that your kids go to school with people of all backgrounds. That will really influence the way they treat others.

2:50 PM  
Blogger The mini ninja said...

Anonymous - Why, you sound strangely like someone I know...hm...who could it be? ;)

(love you too)

2:51 PM  
Blogger The mini ninja said...

Kimananda - I've always been curious as to how the world views us Americans. Do they all think we're pompous, selfish, superior people?

I remember how the Muslim community got treated after 911. It was horrible.

Trish - What a sweet compliment, thank you. In fact, I have always wanted to be published. I used to write a lot of poetry and the occasional short story. (And I have an overactive imagination. :) I suppose this online blog is my first real "public" publication. My dream is to write a book someday. About what? I haven't decided yet. :)

I've never seen the Sopranos (I know, that's bad, right?), but I know how you feel. I'm proud to be Chinese, but a lot of "natives" can really get on my last nerve. I tend to stay away from large crowds of Asians, which isn't difficult in this white city.

2:57 PM  
Blogger "Poozie" said...

You speak of Americans and travel - permit me to share my story - A first-generation Canadian, of Hungarian descent, I was touring Greece last summer with 3 girlfriends.

Our first night in Athens we couldn't wait to head to the heart of the city and dine in an outdoor cafe. No sooner had we ordered than the couple at the table beside us leaned over, "Hello," the gentleman asked, "Where are you from?" I smiled, "Canada. BC to be exact." "Oh, really, that surprises me," he said, "you speak such good American."

You could have knocked me over with a feather. Good American? It was all I could do to nto to correct him with a history lesson, "Sorry, buddy, but I speak English, the Queen's English, same as you."

What did Mr. Full-of-himself think a Canadian sounded like? Doesn't he realize America has regions, like any other country? Slow southern drawls and good ol' boys from Chicaga both speak American, not to mention it's a melting pot, celebrating ethnic diversity, just like Canada?

I shut my mouth and dug into my calamari.

I discovered later,I was the only one at my table who had taken offence. The pompous faux pas had gone right over all three girlfriends heads.

I suppose, in the end, we're every one of us of this world. It's all relative (pun intended).

11:08 PM  
Blogger Concert Josh said...

Leslie - there is a big difference. Let's say you moved to Germany permantly. Would you label your self as Chinease-American-German? or even Chinease-German? Probably not. And that is why I hate that phrase. You don't really see it being used anywhere BUT in this country.

I was more angry about not knowing I was being slammed than the actual slam.. I could care less if that idiot teenage kid likes me or any other white person, I don't live to impress him, nor have I ever really interacted with him.

1:52 AM  
Blogger KjerstenGreg said...

Wonderful topic. I have so many thoughts and questions.

First, I was born with platinum blonde hair, pale skin and light blue eyes. My family has been in America since the 1800s, but we still have a traditional scandinavian last name and I have my great-great grandmothers Danish first name. People tell me that I speak and carry myself very much like a 'native european' (whatever that means), and I am frequently mistaken for a recent immigrant. I would say that my situation is in some ways similar to others with asian, south american or african heritage.

I am proud of my heritage and love learning about the customs of Norway and Denmark and enjoy hearing stories about my ancestors. We even try to cook some traditional Norweigen dishes now and then. My grandfather who recently passed away did not know how to speak Norweigen, but picked up a perfect accent from his grandparents. We all loved to hear him immitate his grandparents and exclaim "oof da!" when he was upset.

I am equally interested in other's heritage and ancestry. I love visiting the local natural history museum, and I absolutely adore hearing others talk about their family histories. I love it when people ask me about my ethnicity and feel like others like to talk about it as well.

I think a good way to get around the 'where you from?' question being offensive is to ask 'where is your family from'... indicating the last name or ethnicity instead of an individual's birthplace.

Now, that being said, I share Josh's hesitancy with the __-american terminology. If people ask me 'what I am' I say scandinavian. I will always be scandinavian no matter where I live in the world. I do not find it offensive whether I got my citizenship yesterday or my family immigrated 200 years ago.

I know people's snap-judgements regarding skin color add another level of complexity, but all americans are immigrants. Greg's paternal ancestors have been in the US since 1710, but they're still German immigrants.

11:03 AM  
Blogger The mini ninja said...

June - Hello and welcome! Thank you for sharing that humurous anecdote. I would have reacted the same way as you.

You also bring up an interesting point - that just because the U.S. is ONE country, that does not mean there is only ONE type of English. Isn't it interesting that most people are surprised when I tell them that China has hundreds of languages and dialects? But then you think about it and it should make sense that China, a large country holding the largest ethnic population in the world, should have so many types of the Chinese language. Myself, I speak Mandarin, the official country language. However, my mother has a Beijing accent (she slurs her words with an "errrr" sound).

Personally, I love languages. I would like to become fluent in American Sign and also learn conversational Russian.

11:49 AM  
Blogger The mini ninja said...

Josh - I didn't realize that Americans are the only ones who use the "____-American" term. I still think that people should describe themselves with whatever they identify with, but you've really challenged me to think hard about how I would describe myself if asked. I've been asked the "what ARE you?" question so often that I am used to answering "Chinese" simply because I know that is what they want to hear.

I am very American, but really, I'm proud to be Chinese. (Just a little sick of Chinese food, that's all. :)

11:52 AM  
Blogger The mini ninja said...

Kjersten - Never in a million years would I have guessed that a blonde-haired, blue-eyed woman could receive the same prejudice as an Asian! What a revelation, and thank you for sharing your story with me. (And to think I used to wish for blue eyes so I could escape prejudice!)

I have no idea what a "native European" accent sounds like either. (Isn't Europe a bit large to typecast it into one accent?)

I also enjoy learning about different cultures. Particular (and I'm biased here), eating the different foods. Bring on the good food! (My absolute favorite ethnic foods: Greek and Middle Eastern. Oh Pah!)

You're right - everyone is an immigrant in some way. Somehow people think some people (white and black) belong more in the U.S. than others (Asian, Indian, Mexican). I wonder why that is?

11:57 AM  
Blogger KjerstenGreg said...

I'm still clueless on the european thing too... probably similar to grouping all asian cultures together. Doesn't make sense.

I think (I'd like to think) we're living in an interesting time where perceptions and prejudices are changing for the better and people are generally becoming more accepting.

I also think that 'american culture' is much different depending on where you live. In DC, I could be considered a minority... in fact I usually am at work and in our neighborhood. I think it is an excellent environment because people stop seeing differences and start seeing PEOPLE.

4:15 PM  
Blogger tara said...

A couple years back I bit my lip and decided to attend church with my Aunt on Easter Sunday. I was still in that kind of "what to believe...?" stage in my life. There was a nice play, and some nice singing.. It all brought me back to some really nice childhood days.

Before I know it, some dickhead pastor is standing in front of everyone talking about, well, you know.. the JEWS are OK and all, but they're wrong, and christians are right. Dude seriously used the term THE JEWS about a million times throughout the sermon. And used a LOT of examples as to why christians are superior and more right. I nearly pissed my pants..

And everyone just sat there, nodding their heads, smiling. I wanted to give him the finger

When people ask me what I am, I simply say.. Are you f*cking kidding?

7:08 PM  
Blogger Rowan said...

though canada isa similar country, we differ in this respect. We do not have a melting pot society, so I think that is where we are more accepting of different cultures. I am your typical WASP, but if you took a look about me, you'd see that I am in fact the minority. With English being the meeting group, and many private languaged conversations going on about you all the time in what only sounds like gobbledegook to the non-comprehending, this is the only problem I see withour sysstem. it is very rude to me that people will be speaking something in front of you that no one else understands. Especially when they are staring at you while they say it. now, I speak enough french to get by, and so, it was interesting to me the last time I saw a married ocuple going on in french, i listened in, wondering what it is those rude folk who speak in tongues are on about...they were talking about the most mundane and stupid things, it really didn't matter. i found that interesting, there was no gossiping, swearing, slandering, conspiring, NATTA! it was innocent and probably just what they were most comfortable speaking.

3:30 PM  
Blogger Jeremy Pierce said...

For some reason most white people simply have never, ever heard that there's anything about the word 'Oriental' that even might possibly offend anyone. It's pretty standard that people who have gone to diverse enough colleges figure it out during college, but this only applies to people after a certain generation. I had never heard anyone even mention any problem with it until freshman orientation, and I'd never heard anyone being called an Asian until then. It's simply not part of the information most white people come into contact with unless they have Asian friends. This is why some people might be preaching acceptance but be willing to use that name. They can be very acceptance but just unaware of that piece of information.

A funny note on the nationality issue: I've discovered from my sitemeter that numerous people have been looking for Supreme Court nominee Samuel Alito's nationality. I assume they're wondering what his ethnicity is. His name sounds Latinate, and some might wonder if he's Hispanic. But the word they use is 'nationality'. The guy has been nominated for the United States Supreme Court. What do you think his nationality is? How is the president going to appoint someone who isn't a U.S. citizen to the U.S. Supreme Court?

I don't think you need to worry about the affirmative action issue. Some schools don't have enough Asians applying to meet their unofficial goals for class percentage, but those are generally the small schools. Schools on the higher end like S.U. have too many Asians applying proportionally, so they don't need affirmative action to get enough in the student body. Asians are actually subject to higher standards than most minority groups due to not being underrepresented proportionally. So you probably would have gotten in without affirmative action, because they very likely didn't include you in the group they were lowering standards for.

3:34 PM  

Gab At Les

<< Home